In comparing a novel and a play, we can identify certain features of the genres. Raleigh, a new lieutenant, is also shocked by the experience of fighting. C Sherriff has presented his play in order to create a presentation of dramatic affects; Explore the ways in which sherriff the viewers are then draw to consider the social division, in comparison to Pat Barkers interest in social class.
Instead he presents Trotter as a comical character with very little psychological depth. C Sherriff has presented other characters, such as Trotter for example, who is considered as an, unintelligent character, who cannot appreciate the finer and more sophisticated things in life.
Get Full Essay Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.
More essays like this: When we become aware of Stanhope mocking Trotter, we can clearly distinguish the attitude developed between fellow soldiers, in spite of class division. Pat Barker, on the other hand, shows a significant interest in matters of social division, in the war and considers the situation of a character, such as Prior a young man of a working class origin who entered the war as an officer and has to face the prejudices of those from more privileged backgrounds.
This is reflected through the way in which the characters upbringing is presented, as well as other additional facts. This is established through their conversations concerning school. Throughout the play we gain an insight of the shared background between officers such as Raleigh and Stanhope.
Furthermore, there is the use of depiction of the different ranks in command, as the Colonel seems mainly interested in pleasing the Brigadier; Stanhope, a captain, is deeply shocked by the loss in action of Osbourne, his reliable second in command.
Although abrupt in tone when addressing him, Stanhope is clearly closer to Raleigh than to the Colonel because of their shared experience.
Trotter seems almost unaffected by the war; alternatively he concentrates upon his daily routine of eating, standing on duty and writing letters home to his wife. However, it is not clear whether Sherriff is expressing his own prejudices or merely presenting an accurate view of how the upper class officers would treat an NCO as most of the negative comments come from Stanhope, who appears to have a very critical attitude to Trotter.
This again creates an example of the class divisions between those of lower classes, within both texts. Which is a deep shade of khaki, by the way. He achieves this through stage directions and dialogue.
Throughout the play there is one conflicting moment within the hierarchy of characters where, for example, Trotter looks down upon Hibbert who is actually of a higher class than himself. Evidently, we see that R. This breaks the tension and adds humor, for instance when he describes the stew made by a former cook: In addition, Barker uses the character of, Prior to illustrate class prejudice at the front.
However, Sherriff does not seem particularly interested in exploring issues of social division. Although other characters such as Raleigh and Osborne seem to interact with him as a down-to-earth, loving character.Explore the ways in which Sheriff presents the character of Stanhope “How is the dear young boy?
Still drinking like a fish, as usual?” The character of Stanhope is introduced by Hardy in Act 1, without him actually making an appearance.
Compare and contrast the ways in which Hill and Sherriff present the impact of war upon men’s relationships in Strange Meeting and Journey’s End and say how far you agree with the view that the relationships in Strange Meeting are more crucial for survival than those in Journey’s End.
Explore the ways in which Sherriff makes this a dramatic and revealing moment in the play. (Trotter, Raleigh and Hibbert leaving for the attack). Sherriff makes this extract dramatic and revealing by creating tension and suspense.
Study Guides. Get your head around tough topics at A-level with our teacher written guides. Learn more.
Explore the ways Sherriff’s ‘Journeys End’ and Whelan’s ‘The Accrington Pals’ presents the emotional and psychological effects of war.
Say how far you agree with the view that it is more difficult to sympathise Sherriff’s characters than Whelan’s. Compare the ways Sherriff presents the main character of Stanhope in Journey’s End with Faulks’ presentation of Stephen in Birdsong Both “Journey’s End” by R.C. Sherriff and “Birdsong” by Sebastian Faulks portray their main characters of Stanhope and Stephen in several different ways.Download